Water-Free vs. Water-Based Skincare: Why It Matters for Your Formula

Water-Free vs. Water-Based Skincare: Why It Matters for Your Formula

One of the first questions we ask about any new product is simple: does it contain water? The answer affects how your product feels, how it's preserved and what testing it needs.

What are water-free (anhydrous) products?

Water-free products are made from oils, butters and waxes, with no water. Examples include:

  • Body butters and whipped butters
  • Balms and salves
  • Face and body oils
  • Lip balms
  • Sugar and salt scrubs

What are water-based products?

Water-based products contain water, usually combined with oils using emulsifiers. Examples include:

  • Lotions and creams
  • Cleansers and face washes
  • Toners and mists
  • Serums and gels

How they differ

Feel

Water-free products are rich and concentrated, and they absorb more slowly. Water-based products feel lighter, absorb faster and suit daily face care.

Preservation

Water allows bacteria, yeast and mold to grow, so water-based products need an effective preservative system. Water-free products are much less prone to microbial growth, though they can go rancid over time and benefit from antioxidants. If a water-free product will be used in the shower, like a scrub, it may still need some protection.

Testing

Preservative (challenge) testing is strongly recommended for water-based products. Water-free products focus more on texture and stability over time. Learn more in Cosmetic Stability Testing, Explained.

Development

Water-based formulas are more complex: emulsions have to stay stable, the preservative system has to work, and the pH has to be right. That's why they usually take more development time.

Organic claims

Water doesn't count toward organic content, so it's much easier to reach higher organic levels with water-free products. See What "USDA Organic" Really Means.

Which should you start with?

It depends on your brand and your customers. Water-free products like body butters, balms and oils are rich, concentrated and travel well. Water-based products like lotions, cleansers and toners feel lighter and suit daily face care. Many brands offer both. Think about how your customers will use the product, where they'll keep it and the texture they expect.

How we can help

We make both water-free and water-based products, and we can help you choose the right format for each product in your line. See our packages or tell us about your product.